Kagoshima
Why Nations Fail: The Origins of Power, Prosperity, and PovertyKagoshima, capital of the Satsuma domain, is presented as both the birthplace of Ōkubo Toshimichi and a center of initiatives that helped overturn Japan’s feudal order. Satsuma’s relative autonomy and independent access to overseas trade gave the domain room to imagine political and economic change; its factories and shipyards supplied an early material counterpart to that ambition.
Setting and Political Position
In the mid-nineteenth century, Japan remained under the Tokugawa shogunate, which controlled foreign trade from Edo and had banned foreigners from the country. The shogunate’s authority was not absolute, however. Satsuma, in the south, retained considerable autonomy and was permitted to trade independently with the outside world through the Ryūkyū Islands. Its capital, Kagoshima, therefore belonged to a domain with greater latitude than the central government’s tightly controlled order allowed.
That distinction mattered in a society organized around feudal domains, strict occupational categories, restrictions on trade, and heavy taxes on farmers. The book links Satsuma’s independent position to the possibility of pursuing a different course: its leaders could consider expanding trade with Asia and Europe and replacing the old feudal economic institutions with a modern state.
Ōkubo Toshimichi and the Political Challenge
Ōkubo Toshimichi was born in Kagoshima in 1830, the son of a samurai, and became a samurai himself. His talent attracted the attention of Shimazu Nariakira, the lord of Satsuma, who promoted him within the domain’s bureaucracy. Nariakira had developed a plan to use Satsuma troops to overthrow the shogun and remake Japan’s institutions, but his death in 1858 cut that plan short.
The political movement against the shogunate later gathered force through cooperation among domains. In 1867, Ōkubo traveled from Edo to Yamaguchi to meet Chōshū leaders and propose joining forces to march on Edo and overthrow the shogun. With the leaders of Tosa and Aki already on board, the agreement with Chōshū formed the secret Satcho Alliance. The campaign invoked the emperor’s sidelining as a rallying cause, but its purpose extended beyond restoring imperial authority: Ōkubo and his allies sought a fundamental institutional transformation.
Workshops and the Early Industrial Program
Satsuma’s ambitions were not confined to political organization. Its lord had built factories producing pottery, cannon, and cotton yarn, imported English textile machinery, and established Japan’s first modern cotton-spinning mill in 1861. The domain also built two modern shipyards. These projects placed Kagoshima within an early effort to acquire industrial capacities before the political upheaval of 1868.
After the Meiji Restoration, Ōkubo served as minister of finance and oversaw the beginning of a concerted industrialization effort. The reforms that followed abolished feudalism, centralized taxation, ended restrictions on internal migration and trade, and introduced individual land-property rights. State-backed infrastructure and manufacturing thus extended a program whose early practical experiments had already taken shape in Satsuma.
Significance in Japan’s Transformation
The book treats Kagoshima’s significance as part of a broader contrast between Japan and China. Both countries were poor and governed by absolutist regimes in the mid-nineteenth century, but Japan’s shogunate faced autonomous domains such as Satsuma, which could maintain independent foreign trade. That political fragmentation created room for organized opposition and institutional change in a way the centralized Chinese empire did not share.
By 1890 Japan had adopted a written constitution and established a constitutional monarchy with an elected parliament and an independent judiciary. The book identifies these transformations as decisive in allowing Japan to become the principal Asian beneficiary of the Industrial Revolution. Kagoshima’s importance lies in the connection it makes visible: a semi-autonomous domain could serve as a political base against the shogunate and as a site where modern manufacturing began to take root.